This is the case I blogged about in May. The 2-1 panel opinion (Khatib v. County of Orange), in which Judges Trott and Wardlaw were in the majority and in which Chief Judge Kozinski dissented, is here; as I mentioned at the time, “The dissent is characteristically colorful, and in my view quite persuasive.” Note […]
Archive | Religion and the Law
Three Issues in the Debate over the “Ground Zero Mosque”
The ongoing debate over the “Ground Zero Mosque” has generated lots of commentary. But I fear that much of it conflates three separate issues: whether the government should use its power to block the construction of the mosque, whether the construction of any Islamic facility near Ground Zero is objectionable, and whether this particular organization […]
Outdoor Burning of Korans Unlawful, Given the City Fire Code
The Gainesville Sun site reports: The city of Gainesville has denied Dove World Outreach Center’s application for a burn permit to set fire to copies of the Quran on Sept. 11, but the church says it plans to burn the holy books anyway. Gene Prince, interim chief of Gainesville Fire Rescue, said Wednesday that under […]
Some Religious Leaders Urging People to Delay Going to the Police with Child Sex Abuse Allegations?
If the account in this story (on the Asbury Park (N.J.) Press site) is accurate, it strikes me as quite troubling. The story reports that the religious leaders’ proclamation instructs people not to bring even criminal matters to the police (at least until they are brought to the religious authorities), and says that “it is […]
Another Prosecution for Criticism of Religion
The Daily News Egypt reports: Prosecutor General Abdel Meguid Mahmoud on Monday referred the publisher of Islamic books to a State Security Court on charges of contempt of the Christian religion. Publisher Ahmed Abdallah Abo-Islam, was charged for accusing Christians of fabricating the Bible and threatening social stability and security…. In [the complaint that triggered […]
Property Rights, Eminent Domain, and the “Ground Zero Mosque”
A few conservative commentators have advocated using the power of eminent domain to take the land on which the “Ground Zero mosque” is scheduled to be built (see here and here). The idea seems to have originated with New York Republican gubernatorial candidate Carl Paladino. Legally, such a taking wouldn’t be as simple as Paladino […]
When May Religious Charitable Groups Discriminate in Employment Based on Religion?
A Ninth Circuit panel issued three very interesting opinions on this subject today in Spencer v. World Vision, Inc. The opinions are long and detailed; if you’re interested in the issue, you should read them. But here’s the short summary: 1. “World Vision describes itself as ‘a Christian humanitarian organization dedicated to working with children, […]
A Brief Guide to Federal Antidiscrimination Law and Religion
I’m about to post something about an interesting new case on religious charities and employment discrimination law, so I thought it would be helpful to post this general summary I wrote a while back; I also hope to refer to it in future posts. * * * Federal job discrimination law provides three sets of […]
A Possible Endorsement Test Case for the U.S. Supreme Court?
In today’s American Atheists, Inc. v. Duncan, a Tenth Circuit panel struck down the Utah Highway Patrol’s practice of allowing twelve-foot-high crosses as roadside memorials for fallen troopers. The practice, the panel held, violated the Establishment Clause because it had the effect of endorsing Christianity. (For pictures of the crosses, which included the names of […]
High School Football Practices and Ramadan
The Detroit News reports (thanks to Prof. Howard Friemdan (Religion Clause) for the pointer): Practicing four or five hours, with a break in between during the hot days of August without food or water is potentially dangerous. To prepare for Ramadan, Fordson coach Walker Zaban scheduled practices at night. Monday’s practice began at 12:01 a.m., […]
A Thought from Prof. Michael McConnell
Stanford law professor (and former judge) Michael McConnell, who represented the Christian Legal Society before the Supreme Court in Christian Legal Society v. Martinez, e-mails this: I had a mischievous thought, which I thought I would offer to your blog: I have a suggestion for the City of New York City, if it wishes to […]
No “Intrusion Upon Seclusion” Tort When Person is Videotaped at a Publicly Visible Religious Service
From Tagouma v. Investigative Consultant Servs., Inc.: On April 8, 2004, [Appellant, Ahmed, Tagouma] fell at work while employed at Arnold Industries. He suffered an acute fracture of his right hand. [Appellant] was later diagnosed with Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome (RSD). [Appellant] sought workers’ compensation benefits and Arnold Logistics contested his claim. While the claim […]
“New York MTA Accepts Controversial Anti-Mosque Ad After Lawsuit Is Filed”
So reports Prof. Howard Friedman (Religion Clause). Here’s the ad: The Complaint quotes an e-mail from the representative of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority giving this ground for initially rejecting the ad: The problem with this ad still is the direct connection that is being associated with the Twin Towers attack and the new Mosque that […]
Ground Zero Mosque (Actually, Two-Blocks-from-Ground-Zero Mosque)
I don’t have anything helpful to say on the ethical, public relations, or interfaith amity questions raised by the ground zero mosque. Cathy Young takes one view, [UPDATE: Christopher Hitchens in Slate takes a somewhat different one, and this Ottawa Citizen op-ed takes yet another] and I know there are others, but I leave that […]
Man Stabbed in Australia, Apparently Because He Was a Criminal Defendant Who Objected to a Witness’s Testifying While Veiled
WA Today reports: The man whose trial has led to controversy over the wearing of a Muslim headscarf in court has been “brutally stabbed” after being stopped in his car, his lawyer says. Anwar Sayed, who a court yesterday heard had received written and verbal death threats for supposedly agitating to abolish the wearing of […]