Rifqa Bary, about whom I blogged before, is the 17-year-old girl from a Muslim family in America who ran away from home, claiming her father had threatened to “hurt her, kill her or send her back to Sri Lanka” because she had converted to Christianity. A police investigation apparently concluded that the girl’s charges were […]
Archive | Religion and the Law
Canadian Airlines Failing to Require That Veiled Passengers Show Their Faces for Identification Checks?
One news story is here; here’s the statement from the Canada’s Transport Minister: Recent media reports have suggested that individuals routinely board aircraft without being visually identified. Under the Identity Screening Regulations, airlines must be able to verify the identity of all passengers before they are allowed to board. Airlines in Canada are required to […]
Prison Doesn’t Have to Exempt Female Muslim Employees from a No-Headgear Rule
So a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit just held, by a 2-1 vote, in EEOC v. GEO Group, Inc. Three Muslim women employees had claimed that the religious accommodation provision of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (as amended in 1972) required the prison to exempt […]
Cultural Defense Accepted as to Nonconsensual Sex in New Jersey Trial Court, Rejected on Appeal
From today’s opinion in S.D. v. M.J.R. (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div.), a domestic restraining order case: The record reflects that plaintiff, S.D., and defendant, M.J.R., are citizens of Morocco and adherents to the Muslim faith. They were wed in Morocco in an arranged marriage on July 31, 2008, when plaintiff was seventeen years old. […]
Decision About Hindu Gods Not Getting Stock Trading Accounts Now Available
I’ve uploaded Shri Ganpati Panchayatan Sansthan Trust v. Union of India; many thanks to Vicki Steiner of the UCLA Law Library for tracking it down for me.
Property Rights for Deities?
Co-blogger Eugene Volokh links to an Indian newspaper article about a ruling concerning the property rights of Hindu gods. According to the article, Hindu deities are allowed to acquire at least some types of property rights under Indian law, though perhaps “only deities of registered public trusts were allowed to acquire property in their names.” […]
Syria Banning Wearing of Burqa at Universities — and Maybe Soon in Other Places, Too?
The Daily Star (UK) reports, Syria has become the first Muslim country to ban the burka, claiming the face mask encourages Islamic extremism…. Government officials made the move despite the nation’s 22million population being 87% Muslim. It came after several European states launched similar measures…. The ban will take place first in universities with plans […]
Is a Patient Who Believes “Jesus Would Save [Me]” Competent to Refuse Life-Saving Medical Treatment?
Mentally competent adults generally have a constitutional right to refuse medical treatment, even when they would likely to die as a result. But how are courts to determine whether the adult is mentally competent, especially when the refusal of treatment seems to be motivated by the person’s belief that God will save her and thus […]
Russian Art Curators Convicted for Blasphemy, Fined
For more on the case, see this post from a few days ago. The conviction was for “committing acts aimed at inciting national hatred and strife,” but, as I argue in that post, this provision has essentially been interpreted as a ban on use of religious images that sufficiently offends believers, which is why I […]
Religious Exemption Law Map of the United States
For background on what this all means, see here. Many thanks to Donna Gulnac of the UCLA law library for turning the spreadsheet into this map.
Fifth Circuit Holds That Texas Religious Freedom Restoration Act Mandates Exemption from School Hair-Length Restriction
The case is A.A. v. Needville Indep. School Dist., decided today; the opinion is written by Judge Higginbotham and joined by Judge Wiener, but Judge Jolly dissents. Here is the opening paragraph of the majority opinion: A Native American boy and his parents challenge a school district’s requirement that he wear his long hair in […]
Museum Curators on Trial for Blasphemy
[UPDATE, July 12, 2010: The curators have been convicted and fined.] The AP reports: [T]he two prominent Moscow art curators who put on [an art] show are facing the prospect of three years in prison … [under] the law against inciting religious hatred…. In one [painting in the show], Christ appeared to his disciples as […]
Federal Court Strikes Down Pennsylvania Ban on Corporate Names Containing “Blasphemy, Profane Cursing or Swearing or [Words] That Profane the Lord’s Name”
I blogged about the law, and the litigation, here; yesterday, a federal district judge held (Kalman v. Cortes) that the statute violates the Establishment Clause and the Free Speech Clause. Thanks to Adam Bonin for the pointer.
Property Rights for Advocates of Thoughts We Hate
Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes famously wrote that freedom of speech requires “not free thought for those who agree with us but freedom for the thought that we hate.” The same point applies to property rights. A free society must protect the property rights of those who espouse unpopular views – even if their unpopularity is […]
Latest Mohammed Cartoon Controversy, this Time in South Africa
The cartoon — Mohammed on a couch, complaining that “OTHER prophets have followers with a sense of humour!” (apparently referring to the controversy over Everybody Draw Muhammad Day — is here; it was published in the Mail & Guardian last Friday. The South African Council of Muslim Theologians tried to enjoin the publication of the […]