It’s here; very interesting.
Archive | Religion and the Law
Big New Establishment Clause Case, on Religious Groups’ Participating in Evenhanded Government Funding Programs
The Supreme Court just agreed to hear Arizona Christian School Tuition Organization v. Winn and Garriott v. Winn, which are the latest cases to deal with the question: When may religious institutions — here, schools — participate in government funding programs that are equally open to secular institutions and religious institutions (or, as here, to […]
Another Call for Governmental Suppression of Speech Offensive to Religious Sensibilities
The Georgian Times (fortunately, that’s not our Georgia) reports that the Georgian Orthodox Patriarchate is calling for a law that would protect “religious feelings,” and arguing that “[f]reedom of speech doesn’t mean right to provoke discord and confrontation, abuse church, religious feelings and belittle state symbols.” The call seems to have been prompted by a […]
Prosecution for Insulting Religion — This Time, Buddhism
InfoLanka.com reported in late March: Sarah Malanie Perera [was] detained in the [Sri Lankan] capital Colombo for allegedly offending the spiritual leader of Buddhism …. [I]t is understood two of her recently published books offended ethnic Sinhalese Buddhists, who account for about 70 per cent of Sri Lanka’s 20 million population…. The 38-year-old, who previously […]
Another European Prosecution for Insulting Religion
[Polish pop star Dorota Rabczewska, also known as] Doda is accused by the prosecutor’s office of the capital [Warsaw] of insulting the religious feelings of others, including by calling the authors of the Bible “drunks and drug addicts.” For this, the popular singer is facing up to 2 years in prison. On April 30, the […]
Court Rejects Muslim Police Officer’s Demand for Accommodation of His Religious Practice of Wearing a Full Beard
The case is Wallace v. City of Philadelphia (E.D. Pa. Apr. 26). The court’s reasoning: 1. Because the police department didn’t allow anyone to wear a full beard, it had no obligation under the Free Exercise Clause to carve out an exemption for religious objectors. 2. Under FOP Newark Lodge No. 12 v. City of […]
D.C. Circuit Panel Rejects, on Procedural Grounds, Challenges to Religious Elements of the Inauguration
As to the use of “so help me God” in the 2009 oath, and the clergy prayers in 2009, the panel (Judge Janice Rogers Brown, joined by Judge Douglas Ginsburg) held the challenge was moot; as to the challenge to similar elements in the 2013 and 2017 inaugurations, the Court found lack of standing, on […]
Religious Accommodations in Court Holding Cells, Islamic Headscarves, and Statutory Construction
An interesting opinion from Khatib v. County of Orange, with Judges Trott and Wardlaw in the majority, and Chief Judge Kozinski in dissent. The dissent is characteristically colorful, and in my view quite persuasive. Thanks to Gabriel Malor for the pointer.
Mojave Cross Decision (Salazar v. Buono) Handed Down
The opinions are here; I might have more to say after I read them. UPDATE: The opinions (six of them) are heavily influenced by the peculiar procedural posture of this case; there’s a lot of talk about standing and about interpretation of an earlier injunction in the case, and the validity of that earlier injunction […]
Criminal Conviction in England for Leaving Anti-Religious Leaflets in Airport Prayer Room
Harry Taylor was convicted of “causing religiously aggravated harassment, alarm or distress,” and sentenced to six months in jail (suspended for two years), 100 hours of community service, and 250 pounds in costs; he was also barred from “carrying religiously offensive material in a public place.” A few details on the leaflets, from Asian News […]
Trinity University Keeping “Year of Our Lord” in Its Diplomas
From yesterday’s resolution by the Board of Trustees: The Board of Trustees affirms that it is appropriate, given this institution’s heritage and culture, that the words “in the year of our Lord” remain on diplomas conferred by this Board. Trinity University calls upon the larger community to respect, honor, and embrace all members of the […]
Cross Memorials on Government Land
A question raised by Prof. Mark Scarberry on a discussion list I’m on, and mentioned in some of the briefs in the Salazar v. Buono Sunrise Rock cross case pending before the Court right now. These two crosses stand in Arlington Cemetery, and were put up in the 1920s through the efforts of the Canadian […]
Obama Administration to Appeal in National Day of Prayer Case
So reports the AP; thanks to How Appealing for the pointer. For more on the decision, see here. Unsurprising, but I thought it was noteworthy, especially since it seems likely the case will get mentioned in the Supreme Court confirmation debates.
Muzzy v. Wilkins
If you’re interested in Framing-era judicial thought on religious freedom, check out Muzzy v. Wilkins, 1 Smith’s (N.H.) 1 (1803) — a little-cited but very interesting case that illustrates how strong religious freedom and separation-of-church-and-state rhetoric and belief coexisted in at least some judicial minds of the era with strong support for certain kinds of […]
Waco
Bill Clinton’s invocation of Timothy McVeigh in connection with the Tea Party movement caused me to recall my review of a book on the Waco massacre that was a motivation for McVeigh. The book under review was Reavis, The Ashes of Waco, and it appeared in the Times Literary Supplement in 1995. Re-reading it for […]