So says a County Attorney’s declaration filed on May 22, 2012 in a federal case challenging the polygamy ban on constitutional grounds: The policy, as officially adopted by the … County Attorney’s Office, states: Prosecution of Bigamy Crimes: The … County Attorney’s Office will prosecute the crime of bigamy … in two circumstances: (1) When […]
Archive | Religion and the Law
A Fraternity Is Not a Monastery
You’d think that there wouldn’t need be a court case deciding this, but now there is, Myers v. City of Chicago (N.D. Ill. Sept. 12, 2012). The question was whether a fraternity could qualify for a special zoning rule applicable to a “convent or monastery,” defined as housing for “persons (such as nuns or monks) […]
Speaking at Notre Dame Law School
On Monday, September 10, during the lunch hour, I’ll be presenting “The Conservative Case for Gay Marriage” at the Notre Dame Federalist Society. Professor John Finnis will respond.
Thugs Win Again
From The Jerusalem Post: Egged [the largest bus company in Israel] and the company in charge of bus advertisements have decided that rather than be forced to put up ads with women in Jerusalem due to court action claiming discrimination against the gender, they will remove all people — both men and women — from […]
EEOC Sues Employer, Claiming It Unreasonably Failed to Accommodate Woman’s Religiously Motivated Garb
The woman — who worked for a Burger King franchisee — sought an exemption from the employer’s uniform dress requirement, and the employer apparently refused to give the exemption; see the complaint for details. Judging by the complaint, and assuming its statement of facts is correct, the EEOC likely has a good case. As I […]
Pakistani Law in U.S. Courts
In past discussions, especially about the Oklahoma foreign law ban and about similar proposals in other states, some people have questioned why American courts would want to look at foreign law. Yesterday’s Naseer v. Moghal (Va. Ct. App. Aug. 14, 2012) offers an excellent example. The facts: On August 1, 2000, wife [Tahira Naseer] married […]
“Civil Rights Agenda” Files Antidiscrimination Complaint Against Chick-fil-A Based on Chick-fil-A’s Speech
The complaint, filed with the Illinois Department of Human Rights, alleges that Chick-fil-A discriminated against gays in public accommodations. Now none of the allegations suggest that Chick-fil-A employees refused to serve gays, or treated gay customers differently from straight ones. Rather, the argument is that “the company’s widely published corporate philosophy, culture and policies make […]
“Zombie Mohammed” Judge (Mark Martin) Formally Rebuked for His Behavior in the Case
The rebuke came from the Pennsylvania Judicial Conduct Board; the letter does not give more details, but I take it that the Board concluded that the judge’s actions in the Zombie Mohammed controversy were improper.
School Board Rents Space to Community Groups, But Wants to Exclude Anti-Homosexuality Speaker
Local10.com (South Florida) reported several days ago: The Miami-Dade County school district is looking to evict a pastor who rents space in a public school to preach. … [Pastor Jack] Hakimian preaches and teaches inside North Miami Senior High School every Sunday.In a recent sermon, he compared homosexuality to drug abuse and witchcraft. Other sermons […]
Ethnic Preferences in Contracting for Arab-Americans, and Religious Preferences for Hasidic Jews
A National Review Online article reports on a petition that the federal Minority Business Development Agency is considering. The petition, from the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, seeks discrimination in favor of Arab-Americans, in the form of a “formal designation of Arab-Americans as a minority group that is socially or economically disadvantaged pursuant to 15 CFR Part […]
Law Professor Calls for Denying Tax Exemptions to the Catholic Church, Orthodox Synagogues, and Other Groups That Discriminate Based on Sex
See Caroline Mala Corbin, Expanding the Bob Jones Compromise, in Matters of Faith: Religious Experiences and Legal Responses in the United States (forthcoming, Cambridge University Press). This isn’t the first such call, but it still struck me as noteworthy. Indeed, the rationale — that exemptions are generally denied to racially discrimination groups, so they should […]
Catholic Institutions Sue Over Contraception Mandate
Several Catholic dioceses and universities filed suit today against the so-called contraception mandate, the Washington Post reports here and here. In all twelve lawsuits were filed in twelve separate federal district courts. There are 43 separate plaintiffs in these suits, including the Archdioceses of Washington, D.C. and New York, Catholic University, and the University of […]
Tax Exemption Law and Camp Predominantly Used by Muslims
An interesting case in Michigan, in which a Tax Tribunal decision was reversed by Camp Retreats Foundation, Inc. v. Township of Marathon (Mich. Ct. App. May 15, 2012). The question is whether a camp was exempt from property taxes; the camp was rentable by the general public (and sometimes rented by the public), but it […]
Australian Juries and Muslim Defendants Accused of Attempted Honor Killings
In R. v. Belghar (New South Wales Ct. Crim. App. Apr. 11, 2012), Ismail Belghar is being prosecuted for attempted murder of his sister-in-law (labeled “complainant” in the opinion). The government alleges: On a day in October 2009, the complainant, her sister Hanife and a female friend went to the beach without the respondent’s knowledge. […]
Prison’s No-Pork Diet Doesn’t Violate the Constitution
So holds Rivers v. Mohr (N.D. Ohio Apr. 5, 2012, just posted on Westlaw today): Plaintiff alleges that Muslim inmates sued the ODRC seeking accommodation of their religious dietary restrictions. He contends Gary Mohr issued a statement on May 1, 2011 indicating the ODRC settled this lawsuit, and as part of the settlement, agreed to […]