So holds Stand Up For America Now v. City of Dearborn (E.D. Mich. Apr. 5, 2012). Plaintiffs (including Terry Jones, the Koran-burning pastor) asked for a permit to “speak[] to the public from the grassy across from the Dearborn Islamic Center on Saturday, April 7, 2012 [the day before Easter] regarding the dangers of Sharia […]
Archive | Religion and the Law
May Congressman Order a Staffer to Give His Wife a Religious Divorce?
There’s an interesting Slate article discussing the question. An excerpt: Rep. Dave Camp, the Republican chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee, is Roman Catholic, and he represents a district, the Michigan 4th, with few Jews. But as anyone with access to Twitter, Facebook, or the rest of the Internet can learn, Rep. Camp […]
Is It Unconstitutional for Laws to Be Based on Their Supporters’ Religiously Founded Moral Beliefs?
This perennial question came up again on an academic e-mail discussion list that I’m on, so I thought I’d blog about it (though I said much the same thing 10 years ago, in another blog post). I think the answer is not just “no,” but “hell, no” — I think it would be an outrageous […]
Asylum for Converts from Islam to Christianity
Today’s Jabri v. Holder (1st Cir. Mar. 16, 2012) is an interesting illustration of how these cases sometimes go; the immigration judge held against the asylum applicant on the grounds of supposed inconsistencies in his testimony (and the Board of Immigration Appeals affirmed), but the First Circuit reversed, suggesting that the inconsistencies are more apparent […]
Foster Parenting and Religion
From BK v. New Hampshire Dep’t of Health and Human Services (D.N.H. Mar. 7, 2012): This case raises the potentially important issue of whether state authorities violate the free exercise rights of children, or their parents, under the First Amendment by placing the children with foster families who subject them to practices abhorrent to their […]
Killings of Gay and “Emo” Youths in Iraq
From Radio Free Europe: Since the start of this year, death squads have been targeting two separate groups — gay men, and those who dress in a distinctive, Western-influenced style called “emo,” which some Iraqis mistakenly associate with homosexuality. At least 14 young men have been bludgeoned to death in the last three weeks in […]
The Irrelevance of Anti-Sharia Laws to the “Zombie Mohammed” Case
As I note below, I highly disapprove of the judge’s comments in the “zombie Mohammed” affair. But the suggestion that anti-Sharia laws would help avoid this (see also here) doesn’t make much sense to me. This is not a situation where the judge “applied Sharia law” in any normal sense of the phrase. The judge […]
A Crime to Threaten “Spiritual Injury” to Compel a Voter
Minn. Stat. Ann. § 211B.07 makes it a gross misdemeanor — I think unconstitutionally, at least as to the “spiritual injury” element — to directly or indirectly use or threaten force, coercion, violence, restraint, damage, harm, loss, including loss of employment or economic reprisal, undue influence, or temporal or spiritual injury against an individual to […]
Court Reaffirms Ministerial Exception
SCOTUSBlog reports that the Supreme Court has issued its opinion in Hosanna Tabor v EEOC, unanimously reversing the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on the question whether the First Amendment precludes employment discrimination suits against religious entities by those in “ministerial” positions. The Court was unanimous in the judgment. Chief Justice Roberts […]
Tenth Circuit Says Oklahoma Anti-Sharia Law Is Likely Unconstitutional
The decision is Awad v. Ziriax (10th Cir. Jan. 10, 2012), which upholds the trial judge’s decision to issue a preliminary injunction. I hope to have more on this later this afternoon. Thanks to Opher Banarie for the pointer. UPDATE: The court basically said that the Oklahoma ban on courts’ use of Sharia law violates […]
New Jersey Court Holds Divorcing Husband Can’t Be Ordered to Give Wife a Jewish Religious Divorce
Under Jewish law, at least as understood by many Jews, a civil divorce decree isn’t enough to terminate the marriage from a religious standpoint — unless the husband gives the wife a bill of divorce, called a Get (pronounced just like the word “get”), she may not remarry. If she civilly remarries before receiving a […]
“Maldives Bows to Protests, Bans Spas”
So reports OnIslam.net: Bowing to protests pressures, the Maldives has ordered hundreds of luxury hotels to close their spas, a decision expected to affect tourism industry which forms a vital foreign exchange source for the Indian Ocean country. “An Islamic party has been agitating against spas hoping to embarrass the government,” a senior government figure […]
“We Can’t Achieve Development by Going Backwards to the Stone Age or Being Ignorant”
As reported by the Maldivian newspaper Haveeru, “President Mohamed Nasheed yesterday called on citizens to reject religious extremism and continue to support the ‘traditional form’ of Islam that has been practiced in the Maldives for the past 800 years,” and in particular said, Should we ban music? Should we mutilate girls’ genitals? Should we allow […]
Religion and Slavery
Reader Ted McClure pointed me to an interesting post on the subject on the MuslimLawProf blog (written by Prof. Haider Ala Hamoudi at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law); here’s an excerpt: If I had to summarize modern views on slavery in Islam among modern Muslims who know something of the subject, it would […]
Saudi Arabia Not Yet Ready to Enter the 18th Century
The Daily Mail reports: A woman convicted of practising magic and sorcery has been executed by Saudi authorities…. The London-based al-Hayat daily … quoted Abdullah al-Mohsen, chief of the religious police who arrested the woman, as saying she had tricked people into thinking she could treat illnesses, charging them $800 (£500) per session. If this […]