There’s been much talk about the trial court decision in Mansour v. Islamic Education Center, a Florida trial court case. I think the court erred, for reasons I discuss in item 3 below, but I think the matter is more complex than some suggest. Here’s an excerpt from the court decision: This action was filed […]
Archive | Religion and the Law
Justice Department Lawsuit Supporting Teacher Who Wants 19 Days for a Hajj
The Washington Post has a detailed story on this case (which is the one blogged about here in December).
Religious Accommodations in Court Holding Cells, Islamic Headscarves, and Statutory Construction
A unanimous 11-member en banc panel of the Ninth Circuit has just reversed a decision that I blogged about last year, and held that the federal Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act secures a limited right to religious accommodations in court holding cells, and not just in prisons and jails. (My former boss, Chief […]
Judge Warns Factfinders: Be Alert to “Groups or Persons Improperly Contesting the Authority of … the Catholic Church’s Official Position or Its Doctrines”
Matter of Zornow, decided by a New York trial court on Dec. 23, 2010, but just recently posted on Westlaw, involves Joan Zornow, a 93-year-old woman who is unfortunately suffering from advanced Alzheimer’s. Given the risk that her condition would deteriorate further, a “living will” was created for her — it’s not clear from the […]
Judge Grilling Parent in Child Custody Case About the Parent’s Secular Humanism
From yesterday’s Atchley v. Atchley: The trial court addressed the following inquiry to the husband. Q. Now, you said you attend a Morning Star Church? A. Correct. Q. Do you donate money to the church? A. I don’t donate money to the church. Q. Do you—does [husband’s girlfriend]? A. No, she has not yet. Q. […]
May Church Be Ordered to Let in Parishioners Who Had Been Excluded from Worship Services?
In Retta v. Mekonen (Tex. Ct. App. Mar. 3, 2011), a court of appeals reversed such an order. An excerpt: On April 12, 2009, the church’s board of trustees amended the church’s bylaws to add a requirement for membership — a contribution of thirty dollars per month. Some church attendees who had lost their membership […]
May Court Order Hysterectomy as Treatment for Cancer, on the Grounds that the Woman’s Refusal Is Based on a Religious Delusion?
“During a hearing conducted on March 1, 2011, the District Court determined that L.K. is not competent to make her own medical decisions and directed that she undergo a radical hysterectomy on March 3, 2011, against her desires. L.K. objects to the surgery on religious grounds, and expert testimony admitted at the hearing indicated that […]
Interesting Religion Cases at the Supreme Court’s Conference Friday
Cert was denied in Cooke v. Tubra, 10-559, but the Court has relisted in the other case I bored you about last week, Hosanna-Tabor Evangelical Lutheran Church and School v EEOC, 10-553, suggesting the Court is taking a careful look at it. Hosanna-Tabor involves whether the judicially recognized “ministerial exception” to the Americans with Disabilities […]
ACLU of Virginia Defends Students Who Want to Post Ten Commandments on Their Lockers
Here’s the Virginia ACLU’s letter to the principal, as posted by WSLS-TV: We were concerned to hear that the administration of Floyd County High School had removed copies of the Ten Commandments from students’ lockers. If the school is treating students’ religious speech less favorably than other forms of speech, it may violate the First […]
Interesting Religion Cases at the Supreme Court’s Conference Tomorrow
I see that two religion cases I’ve been watching are both on for the Supreme Court’s case conference tomorrow. Cooke v. Tubra, 10-559, which I’ve previously written about here, presents the question whether the First Amendment bars a pastor’s defamation claim against the church that employed him when the claim is based entirely on statements […]
Words you can’t say at the Pentagon
The Ft. Hood shooting has finally been the subject of a careful after-action analysis — a study that DOD should have done but didn’t. The analysis was done instead in a bipartisan report by Senators Lieberman and Collins, who lead the Homeland Security committee. Their report reveals few new facts but offers disturbing insights into […]
ACLU Settles with Islamic Charter School Sponsor and State of Minnesota, Continues Lawsuit Against School
Prof. Howard Friedman (Religion Clause) nicely summarizes a Minneapolis Star-Tribune account: The ACLU of Minnesota has reached a settlement agreement with Islamic Relief USA and Minnesota’s commissioner of education in a long-running lawsuit accusing a charter school, TiZA, of violating the establishment clause by promoting Islam. (See prior posting.) The Minneapolis Star Tribune yesterday reported […]
Sovereignty Watch: Vatican Refuses Service of Process in Abuse Case
The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel reports that the Vatican has refused service of process in a widely-followed priest child abuse case. The Vatican has refused service of a federal lawsuit over its handling of the notorious sex offender Father Lawrence Murphy – a move that could delay the Milwaukee lawsuit for months if not years, victims’ advocates […]
Reconsidering Ground Zero Mosque Leader Feisal Abdul Rauf
Back in August, I wrote a post criticizing efforts to use government power to stop the building of the Ground Zero Mosque and explaining why I see no good objection to having a Muslim cultural center or mosque near Ground Zero. But I was also highly critical of Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf, leader of the […]
Court Rejects Claim that AIG’s Use of Sharia-Compliant Financing Violates the Establishment Clause
The opinion is Murray v. Geithner (E.D. Mich., decided today). I think the result is quite right, for reasons I mentioned when the lawsuit was first filed, and when the court rejected the government’s motion to dismiss. Here’s my reasoning from the latter of those posts (though it’s not quite the reasoning given by the […]