Everyone knew the Court would grant cert in the health care cases; the surprising part is that the Court is allowing a whopping 5.5 hours of oral argument for the various issues. Lyle Denniston explains: The Court will hold two hours of argument on the constitutionality of the requirement that virtually every American obtain health […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
My Congressional Testimony on the Need to Narrow the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
Tomorrow morning at 10am, I will be testifying before the House Judiciary Committee’s Subcommittee on Crime, Terrorism, and Homeland Security about the need to narrow the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. I have submitted my written testimony, and it is available here. It begins: The current version of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA) […]
Justice Frankfurter Writes A Former Student During WWII
Regular readers know of my love for antiquarian law books, an interest that extends to letters and court documents. See here and here, for example. One favorite recent acquisition is this letter that Justice Felix Frankfurter wrote during World War II to a former student who was serving in the military: Dated August 24, 1944, the letter […]
Camping Out to See a Supreme Court Argument
A report from the front of the line for United States v. Jones, the GPS case.
How DOJ Can Use the CFAA to Try to Federalize State Crimes
I’ve blogged a lot about 18 U.S.C. 1030, the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA), and how broad readings of the statute potentially criminalize a tremendous amount of entirely innocuous activity. The broad readings of the CFAA also have another important effect: They allow DOJ to try to turn any state crime that happens to […]
The Two Questions of Jones, and the Potential Difficulty of Identifying the Proper Voting Rule
The Justices of the Supreme Court will meet soon to offer preliminary votes in United States v. Jones, the GPS case. We don’t know what the voting alignment will look like: The votes are hard to predict. But it seems to me that there’s a substantial chance that the Court’s opinions might face a puzzling […]
Kavanaugh on the Case for Not Deciding the Constitutionality of the Mandate
Judge Kavanaugh wrote a separate opinion in the DC Circuit’s mandate case that many readers will overlook: It’s based on the tax code, and the opinion itself acknowledges that its analysis is dense and difficult. (“The Tax Code is never a walk in the park. . . . I caution the reader that some of […]
The Supreme Court Plaza on a Sunny Day
Today was a beautiful fall day in Washington, DC, and after the Jones argument I shot this 10-second video of what it’s like on the front steps of the Supreme Court after a 10 am oral argument. Note that the people in line are waiting to get a brief glimpse of the 11am argument, which […]
Judge Silberman on the Individual Mandate
I thought readers might be interested in the key passages from the DC Circuit’s majority opinion, authored by Judge Silberman, upholding the individual mandate under the Commerce Clause: The mandate, it should be recognized, is indeed somewhat novel, but so too, for all its elegance, is appellants’ argument. No Supreme Court case has ever held […]
Reflections on the Oral Argument in United States v. Jones, the GPS Fourth Amendment Case
I was at the Supreme Court this morning for the oral argument in United States v. Jones, the GPS case. In this post, I want to blog my reactions to the argument: I’m going to update the post as I go, so general readers can get the important stuff first at the top and then […]
A Speedy Nominee
The rule of thumb in judicial nominations is that a circuit court nominee with Supreme-Court-level credentials will have a harder time getting confirmed than a nominee without those credentials. Each side tries to limit the Supreme Court “farm team” of the other side. So if a nominee’s resume includes the kind of elite credentials that […]
Panel on United States v. Jones, the Fourth Amendment GPS Case
A few weeks ago, I participated on a panel about United States v. Jones, the GPS case, at William & Mary Law School. The panel featured Steve Leckar, who will be arguing the case for Jones; Melanie Wilson, a criminal procedure professor at the University of Kansas (visiting at W&M); and Paul Marcus of W&M. […]
Florence and the Plaintiff’s Bar
Jess Bravin of the Wall Street Journal has a very interesting article on the dispute among two plaintiff’s attorneys involved in Florence v. Board of Chosen Freeholders of the County of Burlington, the pending Fourth Amendment strip-search case, about who would litigate that case and with what goals. The article is behind a paywall, so […]
Saliva Left on Blood Alcohol Test Mouthpiece as “Abandoned” DNA?
Three weeks ago, I blogged about a Maryland case holding that a defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in his DNA left in a chair at the station house. Here’s a related decision: A new California case holding that a defendant “abandoned” his DNA, relinquishing his Fourth Amendment rights, left on a mouthpiece of […]
Supreme Court to the Ninth Circuit: No, We Really Mean It
From today’s per curiam summary reversal in Cavazos v. Smith, a habeas case from the Ninth Circuit: In light of the evidence presented at trial, the Ninth Circuit plainly erred in concluding that the jury’s verdict was irrational, let alone that it was unreasonable for the California Court of Appeal to think otherwise. See §2254(d). […]