An interesting essay, via Prawfs. If I were a law clerk, I would ignore the names of professors who are signatories but not authors of amicus briefs. In my experience, some of the professors who sign on to amicus briefs don’t even bother to skim the briefs filed in their name. Those who read the […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Ninth Circuit Grants Rehearing En Banc in United States v. Nosal
I’ve blogged a few times about the recent Ninth Circuit decision in United States v. Nosal, which held that “an employee accesses a computer in excess of his or her authorization [in violation of 18 U.S.C. 1030] when that access violates the employer’s access restrictions, which may include restrictions on the employee’s use of the […]
My View of the Second Question Presented in United States v. Jones, the Fourth Amendment GPS Case
This is my second post on United States v. Jones, the case on GPS and the Fourth Amendment. In this post, I want to explore whether the act of installing the device should count a Fourth Amendment search or seizure. My bottom-line is that I find this a surprisingly difficult and open question: Justices wishing […]
PETA Tries to Use the Thirteenth Amendment to Free Whales from Sea World
No, it’s not the Onion: It’s a real law suit. The Los Angeles Times reports, via ATL: People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals plans Wednesday to sue Sea World for allegedly violating the 13th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution — which bans slavery — by keeping orcas at parks in San Diego and Orlando, […]
Revisiting the 5-Cent DC Bag Tax
Back in January 2010, I had the following post on the then-new DC Bag tax: A new law recently went into effect in the District of Columbia, the “Anacostia River Clean Up and Protection Act of 2009″. The law does two things. First, it prohibits the sale or distribution of non-recyclable plastic bags in the […]
Longest-Serving Federal Circuit Court Judges Still Hearing Cases
To my knowledge, the longest-serving federal circuit court judge who is still hearing cases is James Browning of the Ninth Circuit, appointed by President Kennedy in 1961. President Johnson’s appointees who are still hearing cases include Wilfred Feinberg of the Second Circuit, Ruggero Aldisert of the Third Circuit, Myron Bright of the Eighth Circuit, and […]
Re-Post: Bench Memos and the Ninth Circuit
Newt Gingrich has some recommendations for reforming the Ninth Circuit: “Congress can say, ‘All right, in the future, the Ninth Circuit can meet, but it will have no clerks,’ ” Mr. Gingrich told the Values Voter Summit. “ ‘By the way, we aren’t going to pay the electric bill for two years. And since you […]
“Inherently Improper” Searches and Seizures: The Sixth Circuit’s Puzzling New Decision in United States v. Sease
Imagine a group of narcotics investigators decide to turn to a life of crime. They set up drug buys just as they normally would. They make their arrests based on probable cause, they search the dealers incident to arrest, and they recover the drugs. But then, instead of bringing the dealers in for charges, the […]
My View of the First Question Presented in United States v. Jones, the Fourth Amendment GPS Case
On November 8th, the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in United States v. Jones, the case on whether installation and/or use of a GPS device on a suspect’s car to record the public places the car travels is a Fourth Amendment search or seizure. I wanted to offer my thoughts on the case. At […]
Google Suggest for “United States v.”
At least as of this evening, with a search from the Washington, DC area (a necessary caveat): united states v. lopez united states v. carroll towing co. united states v. morrison united states v. jones united states v. comstock united states v. virginia united states v. booker united states v. nixon united states v. watson […]
How to Find A Computer Crime Lawyer
As a specialist in computer crime law, I am occasionally asked how to find a good defense lawyer in a computer crime case. If you’re a defendant who has been charged in a computer crime case, or you know someone who has been so charged, how do you pick a lawyer? I get this question […]
Paul Watford Nominated for Ninth Circuit Judgeship
President Obama has nominated Paul Watford for a seat on the Ninth Circuit; you can find Watford’s very impressive bio here. I’ve met Watford a few times, and he’s always struck me as extremely bright, a moderate, and very much a “lawyer’s lawyer.” For those reasons, I hope he will be confirmed.
En Banc Ninth Circuit on When Using a Taser to Subdue A Suspect Counts as “Excessive Force” Under the Fourth Amendment
The Ninth Circuit handed down a divided en banc decision today in the consolidated cases of Brooks v. Seattle and Mattos v. Agarano, which consider the Fourth Amendment limitations on the use of tasers. The Ninth Circuit judges divided 6-4 on whether the use of force was excessive and therefore violated the Fourth Amendment. For […]
When Should Federal Law Allow Domain Seizures?
My co-blogger David Post has authored several passionate posts harshly criticizing the federal government’s recent practice of seizing domain names pursuant to ex parte court orders based on probable cause. In his post yesterday, David calls the process “nightmarish,” and describes it as a “regime under which you can wake up one morning and find […]
The Latest in the Lawrence Connell Case
From the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: The two Widener University School of Law students named in a defamation suit by former professor Lawrence J. Connell are not only having their legal costs picked up by the school, but Widener has also agreed to pay the tab if the students are found to have defamed Mr. Connell and […]