The Eleventh Circuit has handed down a new en banc decision, Gilbert v. United States, that has a fascinating set of opinions. The question in the case: whether a federal prisoner can have his sentence recalculated to take advantage of a Supreme Court decision on the sentencing guidelines issued after his own conviction has become […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Gun Rights Groups File Amicus Brief in Fourth Amendment GPS Case Advocating Originalist Fourth Amendment
The amicus brief in support of DOJ’s cert petition in Jones is here. The brief doesn’t really have much to do with GPS surveillance, but it’s interesting that it advocates a rejection of privacy as a Fourth Amendment guide and a return to property as a guide — including back to the common law “mere […]
Common Misreadings of Kentucky v. King, and the Difference Between Exigent Circumstances and Police-Created Exigencies
Linda Greenhouse has a post up about the recent decision in Kentucky v. King that I fear misreads the case in the course of criticizing it. I’ve seen the same apparent misreading elsewhere from some pretty sophisticated and credentialed sources. I wanted to say a bit about why I think Greenhouse and others are misreading […]
McCain, Isakson, and Graham to Support Liu Filibuster
Legal Times reports that Senators McCain, Isakson, and Graham are supporting the filibuster of 9th Circuit nominee Goodwin Liu, and that all are citing the same reason: Liu’s inflammatory testimony against Supreme Court nominee Samuel Alito in 2006. Reasonable people can disagree about whether Liu should be confirmed. And the opposition to Liu’s nomination obviously […]
Brookings Event on ECPA Reform
I previously mentioned the Brookings Institution event on reforming the Electronic Communications Privacy Act that was held earlier today. Much to my surprise, the room was pretty packed; I didn’t know there were so many people who know what ECPA is, much less that care about its reform. Anyway, the video of the event is […]
“Choosing the Rule for Police-Created Exigencies in Kentucky v. King“
I recently put up a post by that title at SCOTUSblog.
Employer Sues Former Employee For Checking Facebook and Personal E-Mail and “Excessive Internet Usage” at Work
The Ninth Circuit recently ruled that an employee “exceeds authorized access” to his employer’s computer when he violates the employer’s Internet use restrictions: Given that federal law criminalizes exceeding authorized access, see 18 U.S.C. 1030(a)(2)(C), that would mean that every employee who surfs the Internet, checks Facebook, or logs in to personal e-mail from work […]
Copying Public Website In Violation of Terms of Use Doesn’t Violate the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, District Court Holds
The case is Koch Industries, Inc. v. Does, 2011 WL 1775765 (D.Utah 2011), handed down May 9. In this case, a group called “Youth for Climate Truth” copied the Koch Industries website (kochind.com) and created a fake website designed to look just like it at koch-inc.com. The “Youth for Climate Truth” then issued a fake […]
Kentucky v. King and Computer Searches
Here’s a question for the Fourth Amendment nerds in the VC readership: How does Kentucky v. King apply to searches of computers? Specifically, imagine the police lawfully seize a computer and they wish to search it. Ordinarily they need a warrant to search the computer. The question is, can the police turn on the computer […]
Kentucky v. King and Police-Created Exigent Circumstances
This morning the Supreme Court handed down Kentucky v. King, a Fourth Amendment case on police-created exigent circumstances. This was the case on when police conduct can be factored into the creation of an exigency that justifies a warrantless entry into an apartment. Under the Fourth Amendment, the police can conduct a warrantless search or […]
Help Needed to Identify Law Schools That Offer Classes in Computer Crime Law
I’m trying to identify the law schools that offer courses in Computer Crime Law — a course which may also be called “Cybercrime,” “Cybercrime Law,” or “Internet Crime Law.” It can be either a seminar or a full class, but I am looking for courses that are focused on the criminal law aspects of Internet/computer/cyber […]
No Right to Assault Police Officer Entering Home Even if Entrance is Unlawful, Indiana Supreme Court Holds
The decision is Barnes v. State, and the Indiana Supreme Court divided 3-2. In this case, the officer had come to the home in response to a domestic violence call. He found the defendant, Barnes, outside. The officer and the defendant exchanged heated words, and the defendant started yelling at the officer. The officer threatened […]
The Deep Thoughts of Oliver Wendell Holmes
I’ve blogged before about some of my favorite non-judicial quotes by Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes. Over at the Faculty Lounge, Alfred Brophy unearths the following line Holmes wrote in a letter to Felix Frankfurter in September 1913: We become persons by the increase of negations — of finite characteristics — but there is a cat […]
Brookings Event on Reforming the Electronic Communications Privacy Act
For those in the DC area who love ECPA — and isn’t that most of you? — the Brookings Institute will host an event on Tuesday, May 17th, on reforming the Electronic Communications Privacy Act. Ben Wittes will introduce the event, and then I’m going to give a summary lecture — labeled, much too pretentiously, […]
The Need for Clarity of the Proposed Activity/Inactivity Distinction
In their posts below, both Jonathan Adler and Randy Barnett suggest that it’s okay for the proposed activity/inactivity distinction to be unclear because the “actus reus” distinction has been unclear for a long time and the world hasn’t ended. I think this response fails to recognize an important difference between legal doctrines that rarely arise […]