My co-blogger Jonathan Adler is right, in a sense, that efforts to draw a doctrinal distinction based on the requirement of an “act” are not new in American law. But I think that’s precisely the problem with the proposed activity/inactivity distinction in the mandate setting: American law has traditionally struggled with doctrines premised on act […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Fourth Circuit Judges Baffled by the Proposed Activity/Inactivity Distinction
The challenge to the constitutionality of the individual mandate is based heaviily on a proposed distinction — one that I believe was first articulated two years ago by our own Randy Barnett — that Congress can regulate “activity” but not “inactivity.” I’ve expressed my own puzzlement as to what this distinction is supposed to mean. […]
Osama Bin Laden’s Sons Object that He Was Not Arrested and Tried in a Court of Law
No, it’s not The Onion. It’s an actual letter, in which Bin Laden’s adult sons “demand an inquiry . . . into the fundamental question as to why our father was not arrested and tried but summarily executed without a court of law.” From the letter: If OBL has been killed in that operation as […]
Kevin Walsh on the Mandate Argument in the Fourth Circuit
My friend and Richmond lawprof Kevin Walsh attended the oral arguments this morning in the Fourth Circuit’s mandate cases, and he passes on this report: It was a long morning for everyone, but it appeared to be a good morning for the federal government. Judge Motz, presiding, allowed the first lawyer to speak (counsel for […]
Fourth Circuit Oral Argument in Individual Mandate Case Tomorrow
Lyle Denniston reports that the audio from the oral argument in the Fourth Circuit’s individual mandate litigation will be posted at 2pm. We don’t know the panel yet, so that will be part of the mystery. For my money, the two most interesting things to listen for will be 1) How much time will be […]
The Original “Brandeis Brief”
Louis Brandeis’s brief in Muller v. Oregon, 208 U.S. 412 (1908), is famous for being the first so-called “Brandeis brief” — a legal brief heavily based on social science data. I don’t think I had actually seen Brandeis’s Muller brief, but it’s available in .pdf form here (albeit in short chunks, unfortunately) . Muller concerned […]
Law Clerks and Facebook
On Thursday morning, I’m going to be speaking on a panel on “Ethical Considerations in the Digital Age” at the Third Circuit’s Judicial Conference. One issue that may come up is the use of Facebook, Twitter, and other social media by judicial law clerks and other court staff. I thought it might helpful to find […]
Bobby v. Mitts
The timeline: 1) September 2010, Judge Merritt, joined by Judge Martin, authors Mitts v. Bagley, granting the petition for a writ of habeas corpus in a death penalty case governed by AEDPA. 2) December 2010: The Sixth Circuit denies rehearing en banc. The case is noted here at the VC for the concurring opinion of […]
Al Jazeera English Live Stream
Al Jazeera is a pretty interesting news source to watch for reaction to the killing of Osama bin Laden. You can watch the live stream of Al Jazeera English from here.
Osama Bin Laden Killed by a U.S. Strike?
So reports ABC News.
The Need for A Standardized Law School Grading Curve
To add a quick thought to Ken’s post on merit scholarships and Eugene’s post on curves, I think there’s a real need for a standardized law school grading curve. The key problem, in my view, is that the lack of a standardized curve makes it very difficult to assess student performance. One example appears in […]
“The Campaign Waiting for Mitch Daniels”
I’ve been a fan of Indiana Governor Mitch Daniels for a while, and the more I learn of him, the more I like. It’s not clear if he’s going to run for the GOP nomination in 2012 — an announcement is expected shortly — but Real Clear Politics has this very interesting piece on Daniels’ […]
Ninth Circuit Holds That Violating Any Employer Restriction on Computer Use “Exceeds Authorized Access” (Making It a Federal Crime)
I had though the world was safe from the nuttiness of the Justice Department’s broad theories of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act in the Lori Drew case. Not so. Readers may recall I once blogged about a similar case, United States v. Nosal, that raised similar issues in the context of an employee who […]
Fascinating Seventh Circuit Opinions on Fourth Amendment Implications of Long-Term GPS Surveillance
Today the Seventh Circuit handed down a fascinating set of opinions on the Fourth Amendment implications of long-term GPS monitoring: United States v. Cuevas-Perez. Seventh Circuit precedent has already held that GPS use is not a search, so the issue was what to make of the Maynard “mosaic theory” introduced recently by the DC Circuit. […]
Nevada Commission on Ethics v. Carrigan
VC blogger John P. Elwood argued the last case of the Supreme Court Term this week, Nevada Commission on Ethics v. Carrigan, a fascinating case involving a First Amendment challenge to recusal rules for legislators. You can read the transcript here.