I agree with Ilya that “Judge Vinson’s analysis of the Necessary and Proper Clause is a big improvement on Judge Henry Hudson’s performance in the recent Virginia ruling striking down the mandate.” Judge Hudson opinion was pretty embarrassing on the Necessary and Proper Clause issue, while Judge Vinson gives the issue much more attention. At […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Conservative and Libertarian Alternatives to Originalism
The Federalist Society’s recent Faculty Conference included an interesting panel on Conservative and Libertarian Alternatives to Originalism, ranging from natural law theories to libertarian approaches to Burkean methods. John O. McGinnis moderates, and the speakers include Patrick Brennan, David Bernstein, Brian Fitzpatrick, and myself. It’s a very “meta” discussion, especially in the Q&A.
Activists Meet to Protest Meeting of Activists
News here, involving protests by Common Cause and other groups of a meeting sponsored by the Koch Brothers.
Happy Data Privacy Day
Today is data privacy day. I celebrated by first ______________________ , and then I _________________ . After that, I decided to _____________________ and I followed up with a _____________________ .
Senator Mike Lee Joins the Senate Judiciary Committee
Ed Whelan has the scoop: Lee, a former law clerk to Justice Alito (and son of former Solicitor General Rex Lee), will bring impressive legal acumen and strong conservative principles to his new role. Plus, he’s only 39, so he may be in a position to help shape the committee for decades. A huge obstacle […]
“An Equilibrium-Adjustment Theory of the Fourth Amendment”
I’ve written over a dozen articles on the Fourth Amendment, and until now I have never offered a first-principles theory of interpreting it. I have just posted a draft of a new article that offers just such an approach: An Equilibrium-Adjustment Theory of the Fourth Amendment. It offers what I think is a very simple […]
Should Virginia v. Sebelius Be Dismissed For Lack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction?
My friend (and former Scalia clerk) Kevin C. Walsh has just posted a new draft paper arguing that the answer is “yes.” Readers familiar with the relevant cases are invited to weigh in in the comment thread.
Obama To Select Donald Verrilli For the Vacant Solicitor General Spot
President Obama is apparently ready to name Donald B. Verrilli Jr. as his choice for Solicitor General to fill the vacancy left by the departure of Elena Kagan. I don’t think I’ve ever met Verrilli personally, but he has a very strong reputation in DC legal circles. From what I know of him, he’s a […]
Dashboard Camera Recording Leads Eighth Circuit to Hold that Officer Was “Clearly” Not Credible in Suppression Hearing Testimony
Here’s something you don’t see every day: A federal court of appeals overturning a criminal conviction on the ground that the trial judge’s finding that a police officer testified truthfully was “clearly erroneous.” And the decision was made possible by a new source of evidence that couldn’t be contradicted: the officer’s own statements from a […]
The Supreme Court’s Reinhardt-Watch Continues
I don’t know which is more newsworthy: A day that the Supreme Court hands down new opinions that includes a unanimous reversal of a Ninth Circuit decision by Judge Reinhardt, or a day that the Supreme Court hands down new opinions that does not include a unanimous reversal of a Ninth Circuit decision by Judge […]
Barnett and Kerr Debate the Constitutionality of the Individual Mandate
The Federalist Society’s Faculty Division recently hosted a debate on the constitutionality of the individual mandate between Randy Barnett and myself, moderated by Northwestern lawprof Steven Calabresi. The debate runs about 75 minutes, roughly split between the debate and the Q&A (which included questions by blogfather Eugene). It was recently posted on YouTube, and I […]
The Rise and Fall of Law Faculty Blogs
A few years ago, it was all the rage for law schools to start up faculty blogs. All the professors at the school could post to the blog, making the blog a good place to go to know what a faculty was doing. At the time, I wondered if the new blogs would challenge more […]
Supreme Court Assumes (Without Deciding) That Constitutional Right to “Informational Privacy” Exists in Reversing Ninth Circuit in NASA v. Nelson
The outcome of NASA v. Nelson was never in doubt, but the case posed a significant question of whether to rule broadly or narrowly. Specifically, should the Court take the minimalist approach and assume that the alleged constitutional privacy right in government nondisclosure of personal matters actually exists — and then explain why, assuming it […]
Kindle Editions of Law Reviews
It seems like an inevitable move, as more and more people read books and magazines on Kindles, iPads, and the like. The Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy has already announced a Kindle edition, selling for 99 cents an issue. How many other law reviews have done so or have plans to introduce them […]
In the Spirit of Martin Luther King Day,
here’s John Coltrane performing his song Alabama, a response to the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing in September 1963: For some interesting comments by Dr. King on jazz music, see here.