Last week, a Florida appellate court handed down a fascinating decision affirming the denial of a suppression motion while making clear the court’s strong suspicion that the officers’ testimony was false. The case is Ruiz v. State. Ruiz is a drug case involving an alleged consent search at the suspect’s home. The officers testified one […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Update on United States v. Cotterman, Ninth Circuit Case Applying the Border Search Exception to Computers
Back in 2009, I blogged about a fascinating Fourth Amendment district court decision involving how the border search exception applies to computers, United States v. Cotterman. Cotterman deals with how the government can execute a border search of a computer given that forensic searches of computers can take a long time and require considerable expertise. […]
C-SPAN Washington Journal on Kentucky v. King and Fourth Amendment Rights
I was on C-SPAN’s Washington Journal this morning discussing the Supreme Court’s pending Fourth Amendment case Kentucky v. King, as well as Fourth Amendment rights more generally. Here’s the video, for those interested:
Today’s Award for the Silliest Theory of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
…goes to the arguments made by Sony’s lawyers in a complaint and motion for a TRO in a recently-filed civil case: Sony Sues PS3 Hackers. The argument: You’re guilty of felony computer hacking crimes if you access your own computer in a way that violates a contractual restriction found in the fine print of the […]
Thoughts On the Oral Argument in Kentucky v. King
Today the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Kentucky v. King, an exigent circumstances case. The transcript is here. Here are a few thoughts on the oral argument, with some concluding thoughts at the end, at least based on the transcript (I’m visiting at Penn this semester, so unfortunately I couldn’t make the argument in […]
Privacy Group Seeks Public Release of Thousands of Body-Scan Images of Air Travelers
The BLT has the scoop on the FOIA case brought by the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC). The District Court order rejecting the disclosure is here. I realize that the goal of the public release of thousands of images is to influence public opinion on the use of body-scanners. I gather the idea is that […]
Richard Winters, Dead at 92
Anyone who has ever watched the outstanding HBO WWII mini-series Band of Brothers, or who has read the book of the same name by Stephen Ambrose, will be interested to know that Major Winters has died at the age of 92. A true American hero.
2703(d) Orders in the News — No, Really
There has been a lot of news coverage about the “subpoenas” served on Twitter for information about certain users relating to WikiLeaks. I gave an interview on the legal issues raised by investigation here to NPR’s Marketplace Tech Report (start around 1:45), and I wanted to offer a few more thoughts. The “subpoenas” used in […]
Kagan’s First Opinion
Justice Kagan’s first opinion has been handed down: Ransom v. FIA Card Services. It’s a pretty technical bankruptcy case. It struck me as well-written and clear for an opinion on such a complicated topic — you can pretty much follow the opinion on a quick read, which isn’t always the case with technical legal areas […]
Fifth Circuit Permits Warrantless Government Searches Based on Previous Private Search Not Known To Police
Last week the Fifth Circuit handed down a significant decision on the “private search” doctrine in Fourth Amendment law, United States v. Oliver. Oliver permits warrantless searches under the private search doctrine even when the police who conducted the search didn’t know about the private search. I don’t think the private search doctrine can extend […]
NYT Caucus Blog: “Why Do So Many Conservatives Like Mitch Daniels?”
I’ve mentioned several times that I’m a big fan of Mitch Daniels. He’s still way in the back of the pack polling-wise, and it’s not at all clear he will run. Nonetheless, over at the NYT Caucus blog, and in more detail, in the Times Business Section, David Leonhardt looks at some of Daniels’ appeal. […]
Police-Created Exigent Circumstances: Thoughts on Kentucky v. King
Next week, the Supreme Court will be hearing oral argument in Kentucky v. King, a potentially significant case on the exigent circumstances exception to the Fourth Amendment. The exigent circumstances exception is a longstanding exception to the warrant requirement, but the Supreme Court has carefully avoided saying what the actual test is for exigent circumstances. […]
Eleventh Circuit Holds That It is a Federal Crime For an Employee To Use His Employer’s Computer For “Non Business Reasons” After Receiving Clear Instruction From Employer Not to Do So
Last week, the Eleventh Circuit decided an important case, United States v. Rodriguez, on the computer crime statute known as the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 U.S.C. 1030. The decision by Judge Pryor touches on the same issue that was in play in the Lori Drew case: When does violating express conditions on computer […]
Strange Things Happening With the Exclusionary Rule: The Introduction of Case-by-Case Balancing After Herring v. United States
When the Supreme Court handed down Herring v. United States, 555 U.S. 135 (2009), a case about the Fourth Amendment’s exclusionary rule, there was an interesting blog debate about how much it mattered. Tom Goldstein thought it was a revolutionary case; I thought it was not. Almost two years later, I think it’s fair to […]
This is Not a Witch-hunt
Christine O’Donnell is apparently under criminal investigation for campaign finance violations. (Sorry, I couldn’t pass up the title.)