Back in August, I had a long post, Fourth Amendment Stunner: Judge Rules That Cell-Site Data Protected By Fourth Amendment Warrant Requirement, about a recent Fourth Amendment decision by Magistrate Judge James Orenstein. I wasn’t subtle in expressing my view that it was wrong: I called Magistrate Judge Orenstein’s decision ” an extraordinary opinion, in […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Man Accidentally Records Himself Murdering His Wife, Recording Used Against Him At Trial
From the story in The St. Petersburg Times: Williams somehow activated his cell phone, which then called his wife’s cell phone while he was killing her, Assistant State Attorney Walter Manning told a jury on Tuesday. The voice mail recorded the killing — with Williams threatening to kill his wife, and Mariama Williams screaming in […]
Court Holds that Data About Car Speed and Brake Usage Stored in Car’s Computer Protected by Fourth Amendment
A California appellate court has handed down a fascinating opinion today in State v. Xinos on whether and how the Fourth Amendment regulates government access to data stored in a car’s internal computer that controls the airbags and seatbelts. After a fatal car accident, the police downloaded the data from the impounded car and used […]
Virginia Files Its Cert Petition in the Mandate Case
The petition is here. The petition asks the Supreme Court to grant cert and then expand the cert grant to include all of the other mandate cases that have been adjudicated by a district court. Reading over the petition, it strikes me as more of a political document than a legal one. Or at the […]
What is a “Computer”?
Certainly a cell phone counts, the Eighth Circuit correctly concludes, at least when it comes to the definition of “computer” in 18 U.S.C. 1030(e)(1) of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. Hat tip: FourthAmendment.com
New Blog on Legal Decisions About Biosciences
The site is here, and it offers a “daily digest of brief case summaries of legal opinions that discuss behavioral sciences evidence” in both criminal and civil cases. It is written by Vanderbilt law professor Nita Farahany, who is an expert in this field.
Name the Justice
A Supreme Court Justice once published a law review article called Space Colonization and the Law that had the following in the first paragraph: [Y]ou may think that what I say is pure fantasy and that I’ve taken leave of my senses. Because I’m going to say something about the law and Outer Space-and specifically […]
People Believe What Resonates With Their Beliefs: An Interesting Experiment
Over at CoOp, Dave Hoffman points to a new paper, “They Saw a Protest”: Cognitive Illiberalism and the Speech-Conduct Distinction, by the folks at Yale’s Cultural Cognition Project — Dan Kahan, Dave, my colleague Don Braman, Danieli Evans, and Jeffrey Rachlinski. The paper reports the results of an interesting study on how a person’s political […]
State Trial Judge Refuses to Follow State Supreme Court Ruling
Recent VC comment threads suggest that some commenters at the VC admire lower courts judges who are less concerned with following Supreme Court precedent than getting the law right as they see it. Yesterday’s Washington Post highlights an example of this happening in the state court system. A few weeks ago, the Virginia Supreme Court […]
“Affirmed But Criticized.”
I was reading some cases on Westlaw recently when I noticed a relatively new description in the West summary: “Affirmed but criticized.” I came across it when reading Whitlock v. Brown, 596 F.3d 406 (7th Cir. 2010), for which West summarized the holding as follows: Holdings: The Court of Appeals Sykes, Circuit Judge, held that: […]
One Penny Away from Federal Jurisdiction
Here’s the introduction of today’s decision of the 6th Circuit in Freeland v. Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co.: This insurance coverage case arises out of a tragic car accident. Despite the resources that have been invested in litigating this action, we must dismiss it to start anew in state court because the amount in controversy […]
A Reflection on the Recent District Court Decision
In the last year, readers of this blog have seen lots of posts on a major constitutional issue that is likely to reach the Supreme Court soon. And just recently, a District Court Judge issued a stunningly broad decision holding that the controversial law at issue is unconstitutional. Such a decision would have been considered […]
The Silence of the Legal Academy During World War II
In the new Journal of Legal Education, Sara Ludington has a very interesting article, The Dogs that Did Not Bark: Academic Freedom, Tenure, and the Silence of the Legal Academy During World War II. It’s a provocative article, and worth a read. Thanks to Alfred Brophy for the link.
A Comment on District Court Originalism
My earlier post on Judge Vinson’s opinion seems to have caused a lot of confusion, so I thought I would try again to express my concerns with Judge Vinson’s opinion a bit more clearly. The core problem, I think, is that Supreme Court doctrine has strayed far from the original meaning of the scope of […]
Wikipedia’s Gender Gap
According to the The New York Times, only about 13% of the people who waste their free time by contributing to Wikipedia are women.