Very much worth watching. Also of note, Mike Sacks makes an argument that I’ve alluded to in a few posts: The interesting parallels between Kagan and Roberts on one hand and Sotomayor and Alito on the other. (My own posts on this theme are here and here.) I had meant to blog more on the […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
The Proposed Activity/Inactivity Distinction and the Child Pornography Laws
One of the interesting arguments raised in the litigation over the individual mandate is whether courts should adopt a new activity/inactivity distinction in Commerce Clause doctrine. As I understand the argument in favor of the proposed distinction, the Commerce Clause permits Congress to punish you for doing something that it prohibits but should be construed […]
And Now a Word From Nathaniel Adams Coles
Davis v. United States Oral Argument Scheduled for March 21
I know many VC readers have been anxiously waiting to find out what day the oral argument might be in Davis v. United States, the Fourth Amendment case on the scope of the exclusionary rule that I’ll be arguing. (I mean, what else are you doing — getting ready for the holidays? Bah.) The Court […]
Nineteen Judicial Nominees Confirmed in the Last Week
Nineteen judicial nominees have been confirmed in the last week. By my count, those nineteen confirmations include five circuit court confirmations: 1) Mary Murguia for the Ninth Circuit; 2) Scott Matheson Jr. for the Tenth Circuit; 3) Kathleen O’Malley for the Federal Circuit; 4) Raymond Lohier Jr. for the Second Circuit; and 5) Albert Diaz […]
Is the Constitution America’s Civil Religion?
Sandy Levinson offers a historical perspective on the tendency some have to treat the Constitution as a sort of Biblical document. Interesting stuff, via Jack Balkin.
Use of Night-Vision Goggles Not A Fourth Amendment Search
So holds a state court in People v. Lieng, 2010 Cal. App. LEXIS 2106 (1st Dist. December 14, 2010), distinguishing the infrared thermal imaging device used in Kyllo v. United States: Kyllo is inapplicable to this case. First, night goggles are commonly used by the military, police and border patrol, and they are available to […]
The Definition of a “Courageous” Judicial Decision
A judicial decision that stretches the law but nicely matches the observer’s policy preferences.
Open Thread
Looks like a quiet day here at the VC, so it’s good time for an open thread. What’s on your mind?
The Role of Law Clerk Numbers in the Rise of the Supreme Court Bar
Adam Liptak has an article in the New York Times which is a variation on the “rise of the specialized Supreme Court bar” story — in this case, focusing on the role of the specialized Supreme Court bar in representing business interests before the Supreme Court. There’s an interesting underlying question here: Why did a […]
Herbert Wechsler
Biographies about law professors aren’t very common — we’re not that interesting or important — but if I could pick a professor to be the subject of a biography it would be Herbert Wechsler. Wechsler was a long-time Columbia professor who managed to be at the center of a lot of major legal disputes in […]
Mitch Daniels and Criminal Sentencing Reform in Indiana
I’ve mentioned before that Mitch Daniels is my favorite pick for the GOP Presidential nomination, so I’ve been watching some of what he has been doing in Indiana recently. One fascinating development has been reform of criminal sentencing policy. Indiana’s prison population has spiked in recent years, and state officials realized that they were going […]
Two Variations on “Could the Government Make You Buy A GM Car?”
One of the popular hypotheticals used in public debates over the individual mandate is the “Buy GM” hypo. Whenever someone describes existing commerce clause doctrine as very broad, the response quickly comes: “Do you think the federal government could mandate that everyone must buy a GM car?” The idea behind the question is that if […]
Judges Merritt and Martin Tell the Justices They Were Wrong
The Supreme Court recently handed down a unanimous 8-0 decision by Justice Ginsburg in Abbott v. United States on a criminal sentencing issue. On remand following a GVR, the Sixth Circuit applied Abbott but two judges, Boyce Martin and Gilbert Merritt, just had to let the Justices how wrong they were. Their joint concurring opinion […]
Merits Brief for Petitioner in Davis v. United States — The Good-Faith Exception for New Fourth Amendment Decisions
Today I filed the merits brief for the Petitioner in Davis v. United States, 09-11328, a Fourth Amendment case the Supreme Court recently agreed to hear on the scope of the exclusionary rule for searches made in reliance on subsequently-overturned precedent. The brief is here: Brief for Petitioner in Davis v. United States, 09-11328. I […]