Many thanks to Randy Barnett for his thoughtful views below on the relationship between the Necessary and Proper Clause and existing Commerce Clause doctrine. Randy’s argument is more or less the one Justice Scalia makes in his concurring opinion in Gonzales v. Raich: That the “substantial effects” test in Commerce Clause doctrine should be read […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Understatement of the Day
“Occasionally, the justices slip their personal views into their judicial opinions.” — Dahlia Lithwick and Sonja West
Supreme Court Law Clerks Recall Brown v. Board
Part 1 and Part 2, from a panel that took place in 2004, via C-SPAN’s archives. For a transcript of a similar panel, see here.
The Origins of the “Search Incident to Arrest” Exception
The Fourth Amendment permits the government to search a person incident to his arrest. In a thread below, commenter “zuch” complains about this new-fangled assault on Fourth Amendment rights: One of the fascinating Fourth Amendment questions is how the “search incident to arrest” exception gets allowed to begin with. .. . . We need to […]
Georgia Court of Appeals — Including “Feddie” — Weighs In On Search Incident to Arrest for Cell Phones
One of the fascinating Fourth Amendment questions that courts have recently divided on is how the “search incident to arrest” exception applies to the search of a cell phone. Officers can search anything on the person incident to arrest — letters, booklets, wallets, crumpled packages, and the like — under United States v. Robinson 414 […]
Sixth Circuit Rules that E-Mail Protected by the Fourth Amendment Warrant Requirement
In the last three years, three federal circuits have published opinions on whether the Fourth Amendment applies to e-mail (dividing 2-1). In all three cases, the initial panel opinions were withdrawn or overturned on other grounds, leaving the issue surprisingly unsettled. This morning, the Sixth Circuit handed down an opinion by Judge Boggs that addresses […]
A Quick Reply to Jonathan on the Virginia Mandate Decision
I appreciate Jonathan’s agreement with me that Judge Hudson’s analysis of the Necessary and Proper Clause is flawed. He then cautions, with emphasis added: The Court’s decisions, from McCulloch to Comstock, only go so far in addressing this question. They clearly confirm that Congress can take some steps beyond the scopes of the other enumerated […]
The Significant Error in Judge Hudson’s Opinion
I’ve had a chance to read Judge Hudson’s opinion, and it seems to me it has a fairly obvious and quite significant error. Judge Hudson assumes that the power granted to Congress by the Necessary and Proper Clause — “To make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing […]
Distinguishing Descriptive From Normative Readings of Constitutional Law
In a recent comment thread, commenter Leo Marvin asked an interesting question on why it is so common to blend together interpretations of what constitutional law “is” with what constitutional law “should be.” That is, why is it so common for people to infuse their readings of the current state of constitutional law with their […]
Perry v. Schwarzenegger v. Bush v. Gore
Mike Dorf has an interesting post on the strategy behind Perry v. Schwarzenegger — and its similarities to Bush v. Gore, another suit by David Boies — at Dorf on Law.
One More Round With Tim Sandefur
Tim Sandefur has responded to my post below. To be candid, I find Sandefur’s response perplexing. He seems to want to wage epic battles over natural law versus positivism, with him as the champion of natural law and me as the evil positivist. But the questions we were discussing have nothing to do with natural […]
Slate on Randy Barnett
Over at Slate, David Weigel has an interesting article on the efforts of our co-blogger Randy Barnett to teach state legislators about the Constitution. Very cool.
“Kerr’s Inconsistent Positivism”: A Response to Sandefur
Over at Freespace, former VC guest-blogger Tim Sandefur argues that I am guilty of “inconsistent positivism” in two series of posts I have written. In the first set of posts, I argued that existing commerce clause doctrine can be used to support the constitutionality of the individual mandate. In the second series of posts, I […]
9th Circuit Oral Argument in SSM Case
You can watch it now live at C-Span.
Dahlia Lithwick Endorses Originalist Vision of Federalism, Er, Not Really
I’m generally pretty skeptical about constitutional amendments, for a bunch of reasons. But writing in Slate, Dahlia Lithwick and Jeff Shesol offer a rather strange argument against the so-called “Repeal Amendment,” Randy Barnett’s idea to amend the Constitution to permit 2/3 of states to overturn federal laws. The argument: The Framers of the Constitution were […]