Author Archive | Orin Kerr

A Law-Professor-Blogger Becomes A Justice

Okay, we’re talking a state Supreme Court Justice, but still: As Dale Carpenter notes below, University of Minnesota law professor David Stras, who blogs at SCOTUSblog and Empirical Legal Studies, has been appointed to the Minnesota Supreme Court. You can watch the announcement here, with Stras starting at the 9:30 mark. My congratulations to David […]

Continue Reading 7

Ilya May Be Right About the Context of the Pew Poll

I appreciate Ilya’s clarification about the Pew Poll; as he notes, the question about reactions to words was preceded by questions about politics. Ilya may be right that this implicitly clued in poll respondents that they were really being asked not for the reactions to the words (as the poll asked) but for their reactions […]

Continue Reading 12

Reactions to Words Without Context

Ilya posts below about a poll on public attitudes towards terms like “socialism” and “capitalism.” I suspect the polling methodology explains much of the oddity of the results. Notably, the respondents were asked to offer positive or negative reactions to listed words without any context, not to the underlying ideas signified by the words in […]

Continue Reading 1

Colorado Supreme Court Rejects Good Faith Exception for Changing Law

A while back I blogged a bunch about whether the good faith exception to the exclusionary rule should apply when a search that is constitutional under existing law at the time of the search is ruled unconstitutional on direct appeal. Yesterday the existing split deepened, with a divided Colorado Supreme Court joining the Ninth Circuit […]

Continue Reading 15

Does Georgia v. Randolph Apply to Computers?

In Georgia v. Randolph, the Supreme Court held that the government cannot search the premises based on the consent of one occupant if another occupant of the same premises is present and objects to the search.   The Third Circuit recently decided an interesting question: Does Randolph apply to a seizure of a computer found in […]

Continue Reading 55

Legislating Miranda Rights for Terrorism Cases?

Attorney General Eric Holder suggested today that the Obama Administration may push for legislation expanding the public safety exception to Miranda for use in interrogations of terrorist suspects: The Obama administration is considering changes to the laws requiring police to inform suspects of their rights, potentially pursuing an expansion of the “public safety exception” that […]

Continue Reading 71

Someone Like Me

In my experience, when someone makes an argument that a President should select a Supreme Court nominee with a particular experience or worldview, there is a very highly likelihood that the person making the recommendation has that exact experience or worldview.  Yesterday’s New York Times op-ed page makes the point nicely.  (It’s not true for […]

Continue Reading 91

Shahzad and Miranda Rights

The New York Times reports about the interrogation of Faisal Shahzad, who was arrested for trying to explode a bomb in Times Square: The suspect, Faisal Shahzad, was interrogated without initially being read his Miranda rights under a public safety exception, and provided what the F.B.I. called “valuable intelligence and evidence.” After investigators determined there […]

Continue Reading 158

Panel on Overcriminalization at the Heritage Foundation

Tomorrow, from noon to 1pm, I’ll be speaking on a panel at the Heritage Foundation on the problem of overcriminalization: You can watch online from here. The event will be focused around a new Heritage book, One Nation Under Arrest: How Crazy Laws, Rogue Prosecutors, and Activist Judges Threaten Your Liberty, edited by Paul Rosenzwieg […]

Continue Reading 21

Faisal Shahzad Allegedly Admits to Attempted Times Square Bombing

Reuters has the report here: The Pakistani-American arrested on suspicion of driving a bomb-laden car into New York’s Times Square told U.S. authorities he acted alone, but sceptical investigators are looking into his recent trip to Pakistan, a law enforcement source said on Tuesday. Faisal Shahzad, a naturalized U.S. citizen born in Pakistan, was arrested […]

Continue Reading 159

Draft Testimony on Reforming the Electronic Communications Privacy Act

On Wednesday afternoon, I will be testifying before the House Judiciary Committee’s Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights, and Civil Liberties on Reforming the Electronic Communications Privacy Act. The hearing is a response to the four proposals of the Digital Due Process coalition, a group of tech companies, privacy groups, and individuals that have agreed […]

Continue Reading 18

Powered by WordPress. Designed by Woo Themes