A lot of VC readers who have followed McDonald v. City of Chicago were quite disappointed last week by what they saw as the Supreme Court’s likely unwillingness to revisit the Privileges or Immunities Clause. At oral argument, the Justices seemed focused on the practical problems of reviving PorI, not on whether such a revival […]
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
Does the Presence of a Licensed Firearm Create A Threat to Officer Safety Justifying a Search?
No, says the Indiana Court of Appeals in Washington v. State. Correct, I think: The Supreme Court has repeatedly said that the standard for a Terry frisk is whether the officer reasonably suspects the person is “armed and dangerous.” “Armed” alone shouldn’t be enough, although of course in many cases the two will go together. […]
The Size of the Federal Government
Three statistics: Overall Gross Domestic Product of the United States: $14.2 trillion (2008 figure). Size of the Budget of the United States Government: $3.5 trillion (2009 figure). Expected Federal Budget Deficit in 2010: $1.5 trillion (Congressional Budget Office estimate). In percentage terms, the federal budget is about 25% of the GDP of the United States, […]
The Fourth Amendment, 1900-1905.
Total number of published federal court cases in which the phrase “Fourth Amendment” appeared, from January 1, 1900, to December 31, 1905: 9. Total number of published federal court cases in which the phrase “search warrant” appeared, from January 1, 1900, to December 31, 1905: 6.
Not Exactly the Most Trusted Source In News
Which one of these recent headlines of the tabloid site “RadarOnline” is not like the other? VIDEO: Jersey Shore’s “The Situation” Co-Stars with Sandra Bullock in Re-Enactment WORLD EXCLUSIVE VIDEO: Shocking Violence Inside Jackson Home EXCLUSIVE: Tiger Woods Wife Moving Back In With Him EXCLUSIVE: U.S. Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts Considering Stepping Down […]
The Law of Flipping the Bird
A recent artice, Ira P. Robbins, Digitus Impudicus: The Middle Finger and the Law, 41 U.C. Davis L. Rev. 1403 (2008), tells you pretty much all you would want to know.
Washington Night Life “Has Come of Age”
So sayeth the New York Times. It’s true that the beer offerings have improved dramatically in the last two years.
From Justice to Lawyer
Who was the most recent U.S. Supreme Court Justice to resign from the Court and later return to the practice of law?
Cross-Examining Frank Easterbrook
Something to be avoided in the best of circumstances, and a particularly bad idea here. Judge Easterbrook testified yesterday as a witness, as did Judges Posner and Bauer, in the threat prosecution of Hal Turner. Turner had written a blog post saying that Easterbrook, Posner, and Bauer should be killed for their panel decision holding […]
“How to Write Like John Roberts”
Excellent tips from Ross Guberman, with help from John Roberts. Thanks to SCOTUSblog for the link.
Al Qaeda Seven Unmasked!
It seems that the folks at Fox News have successfully unmasked the Al Qaeda Seven — you know, the terrorist-loving lawyers presently working for the Obama Justice Department. All had their names on the front page of public filings in prominent cases, which is how Fox was able to discover their identities. As far as […]
More on the McDonald Argument: A Reply to Randy
Given Randy’s earlier response to my initial prediction on how the Court might respond to Alan Gura’s Privileges or Immunities argument, I was hoping Randy might weigh in with his thoughts on the McDonald oral argument. I am pleased to see that he has. In this morning’s post, Randy writes: Hey Orin. Given that you […]
The Good Faith Exception and Changing Law: The Costs of the Exclusionary Rule, and Balancing Costs and Benefits
This is my third post in a planned series on why the good faith exception to the exclusionary rule does not apply when a police officer conducts a search that is lawful when it occurs that is later ruled unlawful before the conviction is final. This issue is being litigated all over the country right […]
Liz Cheney and “The Al Qaeda Seven”
Liz Cheney, the daughter of former Vice-President Dick Cheney, was recently invited to imagine how former Senator Joseph McCarthy would have used 30-second TV spots if here were alive today. Cheney gamely agreed to participate, and she submitted the following video: That seems quite accurate to me — although I would guess McCarthy would have […]
A Few Thoughts on the McDonald Argument
Based on a quick read of the oral argument transcript, a few things stood out: 1. The Privileges or Immunities arguments never really got off the ground. None of the Justices seemed in favor of that approach, at least based on the questions. (Justice Thomas, as is his custom, asked no questions.) Only about […]