The transcript is available here.
Author Archive | Orin Kerr
The Good Faith Exception and Changing Law: The Benefit of the Exclusionary Rule on Direct Appeal
This is my second post in a planned series on why the good faith exception to the exclusionary rule does not apply when a police officer conducts a search that is lawful when it occurs that is later ruled unlawful before the conviction is final. This issue is being litigated all over the country right […]
First News Report on the McDonald Argument
It’s brief, but here’s what Lyle Denniston has posted at SCOTUSblog: The Supreme Court on Tuesday seemed poised to require state and local governments to obey the Second Amendment guarantee of a personal right to a gun, but with perhaps considerable authority to regulate that right. The dominant sentiment on the Court was to extend […]
The Line for Oral Arguments in McDonald v. City of Chicago
Here it was at 11pm: I thought of trying to get one of the first-come, first-served seats provided to members of the Supreme Court bar, but I figure it’s a lot of lost sleep for 20 minutes of sparks given that we’ll get the transcript anyway. (For some reason, the Justices refused to release the […]
The Good Faith Exception and Changing Law: The Context of the Good Faith Exception
This is my first post in a planned series of posts on why the good faith exception to the exclusionary rule does not apply when a police officer conducts a search that is lawful when it occurs that is later ruled unlawful before the conviction is final. This issue is being litigated all over the […]
Thoughts on the Reverse Yoo Hypothetical
The comments on the Reverse Yoo hypothetical are fascinating, and I wanted to try to draw some tentative conclusions from them. The most interesting result to me is that for a lot of Yoo’s critics, whether Yoo followed the law or not is mostly beside the point. The primary objection is that Yoo’s conduct permitted […]
Appointed Attorneys Are For Indigent Defendants
That’s the lesson of United States v. Wilson, handed down today by the Sixth Circuit in an opinion by Judge Sutton. A public defender was appointed in the defendant’s case based on his perceived inability to hire his own lawyer. But near the end of the trial, the district court learned that the defendant was […]
Cert Denied in McCane v. United States
This morning the Supreme Court denied cert in McCane v. United States, the pro bono case I worked on over the last few months on whether the good faith exception of the Fourth Amendment applies to changing law. Although the Court denied cert in my case, I think it is extremely like that that the […]
Imagining a Reverse Yoo
I have one more question to add on to yesterday’s post on John Yoo and the torture memos. Let’s imagine what I’ll call a reverse Yoo. Here’s the hypo, with the question at the end. The year is 2002, and the CIA has come to OLC seeking a legal opinion about what “enhanced interrogation techniques” […]
A Comment and a Question about the Investigation Into the Yoo/Bybee Torture Memos
I’ve mostly stayed out of the debate over whether John Yoo and Jay Bybee should be disciplined by DOJ for the so-called torture memos. I’ve read some news reports, and followed the issues a little bit, but I haven’t devoted nearly the number of hours to this issue that I would need to in […]
Philip Hamburger Responds on the Original Meaning of the Privileges or Immunities Clause
I asked Philip Hamburger if he wished to respond to Friday’s blog posts here at the VC about his new draft article, Privileges or Immunities. He graciously agreed to respond. I have reposted his response below: *************** I am grateful to Jim for linking my paper, to Orin for starting the conversation, and to Randy […]
“Fourth Amendment Seizures of Computer Data”
The final version of my most recent article has been posted online: Fourth Amendment Seizures of Computer Data, 119 Yale L.J. 700 (2010).
Hamburger and McDonald[s]?
Thanks to Jim for posting Philip Hamburger’s very interesting new paper on the original meaning of the privileges or immunities clause. With the oral argument in McDonald just a few days away, I’m curious what readers who follow these issues closely think of Hamburger’s paper. I’m not enough of a historian to have a firm […]
Get a Big, Fat Stamp And Pucker Up
Today’s en banc decision from the Ninth Circuit in Doody v. Shriro is interesting on a number of levels — I suspect there may be some interest in it at 1 First Street, for example — but I was also just struck by this paragraph from Judge Rawlinson’s opinion: Our colleagues in dissent chastise us […]
Does the Constitution Have a 14-Day Clause? A Comment on Maryland v. Shatzer
Have you heard of the “14-Day Clause” of the Constitution? If not, you should take a look at the Supreme Court’s opinion today in Maryland v. Shatzer. Shatzer is an intriguing example of how the Supreme Court makes rules in the area of criminal procedure. It’s particularly notable in that it introduces a very rare […]